Scripted Reality

(Taken From My Official Newsletter, Issue 36, January 2005)

I hate reality TV. I thought it would have burnt out by now the way the big money game shows have. Does anyone remember the game show GREED?

Like an unpleasant relative at a family reunion, these shows have hung around a lot longer than anyone would have liked.

What I don’t like about these shows is that they aren’t reality. And by this I don’t mean I’m accusing them of rigging shows. No, I mean the premises are fake. How many people do you know that get stranded on a deserted island, are confined to a house unable to leave and watched by cameras 24hrs a day, or that swap their wife for a month?

SURVIVOR led the way and is the show I hate most. The show is designed to demonstrate the worst in people. It’s an individual event, not a team one, where ultimately, everyone will stab a teammate or "a friend" in the back. I cannot believe at the end of every show, someone bleats on about how they were screwed over by someone they thought was their friend. I don’t get any pleasure from watching people, regardless of background, sacrifice their morals, honor, belief system and ethics to screw over 16 strangers for a large cash payment. It’s hardly the human race at its finest hour.

Obviously, there have been the clones: BIG BROTHER, TEMPTATION ISLAND, WHO WANTS TO MARRY A MILLIONAIRE, THE BACHELOR, THE BACHELORETTE, THE APPRENTICE, EDEN and the list goes on. Actually, the show EDEN was touted to run indefinitely, but it only lasted a few weeks. When they canned the show, do you think they told the participants? Are they still playing up to the cameras that aren’t there?

There is a nasty side effect from these shows too—the participants themselves. For some bizarre reason, a lot of them believe appearing on a game show—let’s not forget that reality TV for all its glitz is a game show—entitles them to a subsequent career in entertainment. Why? How many other game show contestants in the history of game shows thought they were entitled to some sort of career off the back of their appearance?

Half the contestants from the first season of SURVIVOR pursued TV or film related careers. Inaugural SURVIVOR winner, Richard Hatch, demanded to take over as host of SURVIVOR and screen-tested to host THE WEAKEST LINK. Currently, if you’re in Vegas, you may want to drop by the Reality TV Girls Revue. It’s a burlesque kind of an affair featuring the some of the castoffs from SURVIVOR, TEMPTATION ISLAND, THE BACHELOR, and BIG BROTHER. It even features one of the SURVIVOR champions.

The problem is that this kind of fame wanes so quickly, especially with the seemingly exponential proliferation of these shows. Just try and name the castaways for any season then try and match which island getaway these people were on. Can you name which girls went with which bachelor? Very quickly these people blur into the nameless.

My problem with reality TV is that it’s killing the art of story telling. Reality TV is squeezing out good fictional TV shows. Excluding CSI and LAW AND ORDER (and its spin-offs) from the equation, there is very little room for original programming.

So I urge everyone to stop watching reality TV.

If you don’t, I will deploy my doomsday devices. These are my reality TV shows that I will detonate on your screens. For a taste, here are a couple of shows I have locked and loaded unless I see a rise in cancellations.

1. CUPS — filmed on location with the men and women of Victoria Secret. Each week, a camera crew would visit a different store to see the peaks and troughs that occur in the lingerie world.

2. PIMP MY BRIDE — Combining the pluses of the car makeover show, PIMP MY RIDE and THE BACHELOR, Heidi Fleiss hosts this show, where one lucky husband-to-be hands over his fiancé to be tricked out for the ultimate slutty makeover.

You have been warned. Stop watching. Or else.

< BACK TO THE NEWSLETTER ARTICLES PAGE